The Nation / By John Nichols
comments_image -

Crunch Time for the Public Option

Without a public option, there is no real reform.
August 17, 2009  |  
 
 
LIKE THIS ARTICLE ?
Join our mailing list:

Sign up to stay up to date on the latest headlines via email.

 
 
 
 

When Barack Obama assumed the presidency, there was talk that former Democratic National Committee chair Howard Dean might be his Secretary of Health and Human Services. 

That would have made Dean the administration's point-person in the fight for health-care reform. It also would have increased the likelihood that reform would be real. But Dean was rejected. And, now, the prospect of real reform is fading fast.

Dean said last week at the "Netroots Nation" gathering in Pittsburgh that the only thing that made health-reform legislation proposed by House committees (and apparently backed by the administration) worth doing was the public option. In that legislation, the physician and former Vermont governor argued, "the last shred of reform is the public option."

Just days later, however, the administration appeared to be shredding that last shred of reform. The Associated Press reports that, "President Barack Obama's administration signaled Sunday it is ready to abandon the idea of giving Americans the option of government-run insurance as part of a new health care system."

The woman who got the HHS job reform advocates had hoped would go to Dean certainly seemed Sunday to be jettisoning the idea of creating a government-organized alternative to private health insurance Sunday. Appearing on CNN's State of the Union program, HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius dismissed the public option as "not the essential element" of the administration's health care agenda.

White House spokesman Robert Gibbs said pretty much the same thing when he appeared Sunday on the CBS News program Face the Nation.

"What the president has said is in order to inject choice and competition…people ought to be able to have some competition in that market," said Gibbs.

Pressed on whether the administration was abandoning the public option, Gibbs would only say that, "The president has thus far sided with the notion that that can best be done with a public option."

Startlingly, the clearest signal that the administration is preparing to jettison the public option came from Obama himself. Speaking at a town hall event in Colorado, the President referred to the public plan as merely a "sliver" of his reform agenda and said: "The public option, whether we have it or we don't have it, is not the entirety of healthcare reform."

On this, Obama is right. The public option has already been so dumbed-down and neutered that it is little more than a sliver. The problem is that it may be the only sliver of real reform in his program.

Even with a robust public option, the president's initiative looks a lot like a bailout for the insurance industry -- in stark contrast to the a single-payer reform that would replace industry profiteering with a not-for-profit system like Medicare.

Without a public option, there is no real reform.

Dean argued in Pittsburgh that: "The public option is (incremental reform)... But there is no incrementalism without the public option."

In fact, without the public option, the Obama approach -- and that of compromise-prone Democrats in Congress -- looks increasingly like a step in the wrong direction.

That's because the "reforms" currently under consideration threaten to undermine Medicare and Medicaid -- with radical cost-cutting schemes -- while steering hundreds of billions in federal dollars into the accounts of for-profit insurers and the pharmaceutical industry.

This is not "change we can believe in." This is change that serious reformers will find "very difficult" to support, as Congresswoman Eddie Bernice Johnson, D-Texas, said Sunday on CNN. Johnson explained that progressives would have a tough time backing legislation that did not include a public option.
submit to reddit
Without a public option, there is no real reform.

-
Email
Print
Share
LIKED THIS ARTICLE? JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST
Stay up to date with the latest AlterNet headlines via email
See more stories tagged with: obama, health care, white house, gibbs, public option

The "POM" Pomegranate Scam: The Truth Behind the Company and Its Billionaire Owners

  •  

How I Became Stephen Colbert's Lawyer -- And Joined the Fight to Rescue Our Democracy from Citizens United

9 Great Freethinkers and Religious Dissenters in History

How the US Sold Africa to Multinationals Like Monsanto, Cargill, DuPont, PepsiCo and Others

  •  

Rapping Republicans? 6 Hilarious Moments When Conservatives Tried -- and Failed -- to Be Cool

How "No Child Left Behind" Unleashed a Nationwide Epidemic of Cheating

10 Amazing Things You'll Want to Know About This Week

Bill Moyers: When Will Americans Face the Horrific Truth? We're a Nation of Torturers

How Many Anti-Pot Politicians Will be Ousted Before They Realize the Will of the Majority?

The GOP's Played-Out Race Card

How the Memory of a Prison Massacre Helped Ignite the Libyan Revolution

The Best and the Greediest? Ivy League Students Are Still Heading to Wall Street

Photo by bloomsberries, Flickr Creative Commons
  •  

One Homeowner's Uphill Battle with Wells Fargo and Goldman Sachs Shows How Badly The Courts are Stacked Against Ordinary People

Roseanne Barr on Presidential Run: Two Major Parties Are a 'Bunch of Prostitutes Who Work for Big Money'

  •  

Working With Your Rapist as Your Supervisor? The Widespread Sexual Abuse of Women in Farm Work

  •  

Why Mobility in America Is in the Dumpster

  •  

New Wave of Shareholder Activism Aims to Make Corporations Behave Better--Whether They Like it Or Not

Does Eating Organic Food Make You Selfish?

  •  

Collateral Damage in the War on Protesters: Neighbors of the NATO3 Cuffed, Held at Gunpoint

  •  

Oregon's Assault on Teachers

Advertisement
Most Read
Most Emailed
Most Discussed
On REDDIT
On DIGG
 
loading most read content ..
Advertisement
Fox, Breitbart, and Ricketts Try to Bring Back D'Souza's Pseudo-Birtherism

By Steve M | No More Mister Nice Blog

 
 
Activists Speak Out Against Lack of Access to Bradley Manning

By Agence France Presse

 
 
NYPD Catches Sexual Assailant, Then Lets Him Go Free Because He Didn't Feel Like Being Questioned

By Jill F | Feministe

 
 
Gov. Scott Orders Purging of Florida’s Voter Rolls - Just in Time For Prez Election

By Adele Stan | Washington Monthly

 
 
Abortion Clinics Across Country Put On Alert In Wake of Georgia Clinic Arson Cases

By Robin Marty | RH Reality Check

 
 
Former GOP Congresswoman Blasts New GOP Women’s Caucus: ‘They’re Not Voting In Best Interest Of All Women’

By Josh Israel | ThinkProgress

 
 
Debbie Wasserman Schulz is Wrong on Wisconsin

By LaFeminista | DailyKos

 
 
Pro-Coal Group Pays People to Wear Its Shirts at EPA Hearing

By Heather Moyer | Sierra Club

 
 
Kids Inundate NY Governor With Concerns About Fracking

By Seth Gladstone | Food and Water Watch

 
 
Shareholders, Top Doctors Demand McDonald's Assess its Health Impacts

By Sara Deon | Civil Eats

 
MORE
 
 
MORE
 
 
loading ...
POWERED BY DIGG'S USERS
ABOUT DIGG
 
[ page served from web 1 ]