Good News/Bad News September 19, 2002

By Matthew Wheeland, AlterNet. Posted September 19, 2002.

Bad News comes first, per usual:

It's been an busy week for biotech crops. The Soil Association, a UK-based organic farming group, released a report entitled "Seeds of Doubt" about the utter failure of GM crops to live up to the promises of biotech seed companies.

According to the Soil Association, the planting of GM crops has cost U.S. farmers $12 billion in lost exports to countries with bans on GM foods, as well as having a lower yield than non-GM crops, and increasing the amount of pesticides used in farming.

Simultaneous with this report were the bleatings of spinmeisters and revisionists, who are hoping to encourage the EU to lift its ban on biotech food. The American Soybean Association released a report called "Let The Facts Speak for Themselves," and an ASA representative is claiming that groups like the Soil Association are "hoodwinking" the thinking public about GM crops. (Roughly 95 percent of soybeans grown in the U.S. are GM, by the way...)

Meanwhile, a similar skirmish is developing in Brazil. Brazil has officially banned the growing and import of GM crops, and Brazil's second-largest meat exporter has announced it will export only GM-free meat, which includes, for the first time, meat from animals that were fed GM crops.

Meanwhile, the head of a biotech investment group in Brazil has made the claim that GM crops will actually a> be increasing production on Brazil's already-arable land instead of plowing under more rainforest. Despite the fact that GM crops are a failure, they are urging the government to remove the ban or be left behind.

Here's a really stupid idea: a Connecticut scientist is urging the production of transgenic fish, that splicing growth hormones into a fish's DNA will allow it to reach "market size" sooner. This hormone has been shown to increase growth by up to 600 percent! What will happen when one of these fish escapes into the wild? The world will be overrun by half-ton GM salmon! Moby-Dick part two, apparently.

Six-hundred pound salmon, glow-in-the-dark mice, prehensile foreheads -- why can we not stop screwing around with the genetic structure? A report this week from MIT shows that cloning creates hundreds of genetic anomalies in the cloned creature, and is, to say the least, "very inefficient."

Good old Dubya: For the first time in six years, the annual EPA report on air pollution will say nothing about climate change. The Bush Administration has pulled the chapter on global warming because the EPA has already released two reports this year about this problem. Two's enough, right? It's gonna be OK now, right? Let's all just look away . . . Hey, what's "Free Willy" up to this week?

Meanwhile, good old Gale Norton (who was recently cited for contempt of court for her dealings with Native Americans) has given us a great eco-double-whammy: First she tells us that Dubya should veto any energy bill that doesn't permit drilling in the Alaska Nat'l Wildlife Refuge, and then lets the public know that our input is not necessary in the hearings to develop a new trans-Alaska pipeline. What does the public have to do with this, anyway?

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from AlterNet! Sign up now »