comments_image -

Calling All Shoppers: On Grocery Store Loyalty Cards

Besides increasing their bottom line -- and you thought you were saving some bucks -- grocery store companies are also taking a privileged peek at your personal information.
 
 
LIKE THIS ARTICLE ?
Join our mailing list:

Sign up to stay up to date on the latest headlines via email.

 
 
 
 

Grocery store loyalty cards ask consumers to trade away extremely detailed personal information in return for the promise of savings -- a promise that a few informal studies imply is inflated or even mythical. In this article, I want to focus on loyalty cards as part of a broader context: the profiling increasingly being introduced in grocery stores and other retailers. While there are certainly potential benefits to these technologies, I believe that the tradeoffs that you have to make for the convenience and claimed lower prices aren't worth it.

Deals?

The usual rationale for loyalty cards is that it makes stores more efficient at stocking their shelves with products you want, and allows them to pass the savings on to you.

If you think about this for a moment, it doesn't make sense. If all the grocery stores want is to improve their efficiency, they just need to know what items are being sold and what items are bought at the same time. There's no reason for them to need loyalty cards for this. They can record all of this information without knowing who was making the purchases.

Unsurprisingly, then, the few informal studies that have been done so far have shown that claims of savings by supermarkets may be largely inflated. For example, some stores appear to raise their base prices after introducing a card, and simply have the "discount" from the card reduce the price to its pre-card level. If you have a card, you're saving compared to the people who don't have cards -- but not when compared against the prices before cards were introduced.

In fact, the reason that stores introduce cards is so that they can profile and target their customers more accurately -- not to give you savings, but to increase their bottom line. Additionally, your personal information can be sold or traded to third parties.

One way that grocery stores create profiles is by the use of data mining. Data mining is a process that is used to predict future behaviors and trends by discerning patterns and relationships from large amounts of warehoused raw (from disparate sources) data through the use of statistics and other mathematical techniques*.

There are positive aspects to data mining such as fraud detection and identification of items that are commonly bought together. But there is a darker side to data mining too.

Use the address information from your loyalty card application to match up your shopping history with data from other databases or public records (income, how much you paid for your house), and now the grocery store knows what kinds of "specials" to offer you -- or not offer you, as the case may be. Price discrimination is thus one consequence of data mining and profiling.

Even worse, information about your shopping habits can be accessed with a subpoena or warrant and used against you in court proceedings. In a well-publicized "trip-and-fall" case in California, a man shopping at a Southern California grocery store sued after falling in one of the aisles. It was reported (although the store has since denied it) that the store threatened to use his shopping history -- which included large amounts of alcohol -- against him in the proceedings.

Some states limit the types of information that a grocery store can collect from you when you register for a loyalty card. For example, California state law prohibits a grocery store from requiring that you turn over your social security card or your driver's license number. However, data matching techniques mean that this provides very little protection to your privacy rights.

Where Do We Go From Here?

Surveillance doesn't come all at once, it often comes incrementally. Fifteen years ago, the thought of cameras everywhere was shocking and abhorrent. Now, there are cameras in stores, banks, on the sides of buildings, on the roads, at intersections and restaurants.

submit to reddit

-
Email
Print
Share
LIKED THIS ARTICLE? JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST
Stay up to date with the latest AlterNet headlines via email
Alternet Special Coverage - Occupy Wall Street
Advertisement
Most Read
Most Emailed
Most Discussed
On REDDIT
On DIGG
 
loading most read content ..
Advertisement
The Afghanistan Report the Pentagon Doesn't Want You to Read

By Staff | AlterNet

 
 
New Hampshire GOP Reps Offer Bill to Eliminate Lunch Breaks for Workers

By Booman | Booman Tribune

 
 
Montana Ban On Corporate Campaigning Heading To U.S. Supreme Court

By Steven Rosenfeld | AlterNet

 
 
$6.2 Million Settlement for Protesters Arrested at 2003 Iraq War Demonstration

By Staff | AlterNet

 
 
Running Out of Oxygen? Gingrich Loses Crucial Campaign Donor

By Ed Kilgore | Washington Monthly Political Animal

 
 
FBI File Chronicled Steve Jobs' LSD Use

By Hunter R. Slaton | The Fix

 
 
Will Millennials Back Obama in 2012?

By Bill Moyers | BillMoyers.com

 
 
Financial Services Committee Chair Rep. Bachus is Investigated for Insider Trading

By Staff | AlterNet

 
 
Obama's Savvy Plan to Circumvent Religious Groups' Freak Out Over Contraception

By Jodi Jacobson | RH Reality Check

 
 
Is the Catholic Church Just a Super PAC in Robes?

By Steve M. | No More Mister Nice Blog

 
 
 
Reverend Billy Talen
 
 
 
loading ...
POWERED BY DIGG'S USERS
 
[ page served from web 1 ]