Disability, Prenatal Testing and the Case for a Moral, Compassionate Abortion
It's hard to imagine this test wouldn't be the instigation of selective abortions, since many women with prenatal diagnoses of Down syndrome currently abort, he said. "It's search and destroy that we do that now with Downs," he said. "And to what benefit do we do that? If we look at the statistics or surveys that come from families that have raised a Downs individual, 97 percent said it was rewarding."
It's a life worth living, and many see that, says Amy Julia Becker, who has written extensively about her daughter with Down syndrome. Heart conditions and respiratory troubles often suffered by those with Down syndrome can be treated, life expectancy has risen from 25 to 60, and by all accounts, raising a son or daughter with Down syndrome can be a wonderful gift. The numbers are tricky, but Becker says that about 70 percent of babies prenatally diagnosed with Down syndrome are aborted.
"Ultimately, the problem is that we have a society that says it's okay to kill unborn babies," Rudd told me. "If that weren't permissible, this information wouldn't be misused." Prenatal testing in a country with legal abortion lets parents decide if that child is "good enough" to live, he said. But as imperfect, capricious, sinful beings, how do we figure we're smart enough, or good enough, to judge anybody else's shot at life?
"Who are we to say that cystic fibrosis is such an overwhelmingly terrible disease that they shouldn't be allowed to live?" Rudd said. "Do we say that about a one-year-old who is diagnosed? What's different about a younger child?"
There are a lot of pieces to this pie, so I'm going to address them problem-by-problem. Ready? Here we go. This article:
- Fetishizes disability.
- Dehumanizes children.
- Downplays economic concerns and long-term viability.
- Minimizes the suffering of children and caregivers.
- Is logically inconsistent.
- Conflates fetuses with born children, and therefore
- Devalues labor, delivery and motherhood.
Before we go any farther, here is my main point: Having an abortion to prevent a child from being born with Down syndrome or another disability can be a positive moral choice. Okay, now let's go on (assuming you're not already plotting my demise). Continue reading....