comments_image Comments

New Dating Study Promotes Old Gender Stereotypes

From the Charlotte Observer:"A forthcoming study by a Duke University researcher and several colleagues confirms what not-so-thin women and short, broke men have long suspected: They don't get nearly as much romantic attention as skinny women and tall, financially secure guys." You need a study for that? Here, Igot a study. It's called pay my rent, food, and Netflix. Fund that, science people. The study, out of the University of Chicago, is still under peer review before publication. But here's what we know: analyzing 22,000 online daters, researchers found that "women put a premium on income and height when deciding which men to contact." They did the math: the study showed that a 5-foot-9-inch man needs to make $30,000 more than a 5-foot-10-inch one to be as successful in the dating pool. Men in the study demonstrated a strong, and depressing, preference for women with a BMI of 18 or 19, which basically means if you're 5' 6" you've gotta weigh 115. So okay, women want men who can afford to take them to dinner, but the men don't want us to eat. This should work just fine. Sarcasm aside, I'm still annoyed with this study -- or at least, to some degree, this article about it -- and the way it only, and unnecessarily, perhaps even misleadingly,perpetuates and underscores that same-old same-old depressing, needlessly divisive message: "The only thing men and women have in common is that they're shallow." 'Cause here's the thing: the article and the researchers talk about what a fertile field for study these online sites are, because there are just so many people on them. Right: there are just so many people on them. That's why people go in -- or at least online -- with those faux-"high" standards. Because they can. There are so many eligible singles there, at least in urban and urbanish areas, that you can afford to impose a minimum height or maximum BMI standard. You know? Then later, at a party, you happen across someone who -- for whatever ineffable reason -- makes your heart go pitter-pat, maybe someone whose attributes you wouldn't have click-clicked and checklisted, and boom, you give them a chance. I'm not saying some people aren't shallow, but still. As the article, to be fair, does state: "Since the study focuses on first impressions and initial contacts rather than marriage, it doesn't rule out the chance of true love winning despite appearance or income. 'If you had to sit down and write what you wanted in your dream guy, most girls would write 'tall, hot and well-off,'" said Kari Castle, a 27-year-old online dater in Charlotte. 'But in reality, is that the only thing they'd settle for? Probably not.'" Right. So, I guess, since the study doesn't really tell us much, the reporter is forced to fill in with dumb cranky unhelpful -- and dare I say self-fulfilling -- quotes like, "It's got nothing to do with anything but green," [said one bachelor]. "If you've got enough money, you'll have women swarming all over you." Attitude, people! Actually, it might be a guy in the comments who said it best: "If you think women will only like you if you have a sizable bank account, you are the one who makes that happen." This post originally appeared at