Home
Archive
Newsletters
Video
Blogs
Discuss
About
Search
Donate
Advertise

Reproductive Justice and Gender

Laura Bush Was Pro-Choice -- and Dozens of Other Things You Never Knew About America's First Ladies

By Carl Sferrazza Anthony, Huffington Post. Posted February 6, 2009.


The media have long treated first ladies as caricatures instead of people. What will that mean for Michelle Obama?
Advertisement
Upcoming AlterNet stories on Digg

Among the many times I had the chance to interview Hillary Rodham Clinton as first lady, on and off the record, one remark she made still lingers with me:

"Who I really am seems less important than what different groups want me to represent."

It really echoed for me the week before Barack Obama's election, as I sat in the White House Yellow Oval Room, a ray of the waning Indian Summer sun slanted across the lap of the outgoing first lady, who had gathered a group of historians, journalists and preservationists around her. She was reflective, the house strangely still. To the historical imagination it was like a palace before a revolution -- in this case, a peaceful election as much a shift of the mind as in policy.

The Obama election has given even the opposition a sense that the nation as a whole had learned to see a Hawaiian-born son of a white woman and an African man who came from Illinois not by any one of those labels, but as a unique, individual, human being. If history holds up, however, the irony is that most folks might not cut his wife, Michelle, that slack.

To me, Laura Bush has always been articulate about her real beliefs, but then again, I actually followed her words and weighed her deeds carefully. It's my business. I do think her Cheshire Cat smile misled many in the media and public to caricature her as a "Stepford wife."

She is a word person who chooses what she says carefully, a habit that made her quotably bland -- no matter how honest her sentiment. This day, she did not restrain her words. She spoke of a genuine regret as she reflected on her incumbency.

It was not really until the second term was under way that it hit her -- a first lady has the power to directly affect the real life of real people. It was an evolving realization but it seemed to convince her when she read a letter from a woman whose life was saved while watching a public service commercial Laura Bush had made about the warning signs of a heart attack for women -- and realized she was having one right then. She got to a hospital before she died.

The public record, however, shows that Laura Bush's campaign for disseminating information about heart disease in women was a small part of her work.

It has included: her prompting increased public museum and library funding; a long-term and diversified advocacy for Afghanistan women; persistent international protest of Burma's human-rights violations and her aid to Burmese refugees; shaping Reading First, which utilizes proven instruction methods to ensure proficiency by the fourth grade; holding regional conferences on training for state and local efforts for at-risk youth; introducing the first breast-cancer prevention effort in Saudi Arabia -- where screenings increased fivefold after her effort; mobilizing the private sector to match federal efforts combating malaria in Africa ...  the list is extensive.

All this, along with offering nuanced responses to issues ranging from stem-cell research to same-sex marriage. In her first days as first lady, she joined Pat Nixon, Betty Ford, Rosalynn Carter, Nancy Reagan, Barbara Bush and Clinton as the seventh consecutive first lady to state that she is pro-choice.

Does anybody know this? I doubt it. By Inauguration Day 2001, the caricature of Laura Bush as a prim librarian had been solidified -- a result of the George W. Bush campaign's "anti-Hillary" strategy and the national media toeing the line.

Even then, the fact that Laura Bush read the complete works of Truman Capote serially in order to plumb the mind of the author -- not a common trait among West Texas housewives -- was largely ignored by reporters covering her. Then, following Sept. 11, it was the media -- not the White House -- that crowned her "comforter in chief," who was asked how to explain it all to frightened children.

The same day Barack Obama was elected, news broke that Laura Bush had gone public with her conflict with Vice President Dick Cheney on a pending landmark ocean-preservation act -- although understandably the main story was Obama's election. Still, after the post-election glow and the holidays, there was a Jan. 7 announcement that the president sided with her and enacted it.

The enactment made the green news, but as for the first lady's role in it? Barely a blink in the blogs. It didn't fit the conventional narrative.


Digg!    Share on facebook   submit to reddit    Bookmark on Delicious   Stumble This  

See more stories tagged with: media, hillary clinton, first ladies, laura bush, michelle obama

Carl Sferrazza Anthony is historian of the National First Ladies Library and the author of several books, including the two-volume history, First Ladies, a history of the role's evolution and political power. He also has written biographies of Jacqueline Kennedy, Florence Harding and Nellie Taft.

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from Reproductive Justice and Gender! Sign up now »


Advertisement
Advertisement

 

Comments Turn comments off sitewide Give us feedback »
Comments closed.
The comments for this story have been closed. Thank you to everyone who participated.
View:
Stuff It
Posted by: colleenwhalen on Feb 9, 2009 3:13 PM   
Current rating: Not yet rated    [1 = poor; 5 = excellent]
I find it incredible that the author is PRAISING Laura Bush for her many "good deeds" for women's rights and literacy. Why is this crap being published on a website that is left wing and progressive?

Geez-O-Pete!

Now about Laura Bush being a voice for women's rights and literacy....she has been completely silent about American women soldiers being raped by in Iraq by private contractors and American soldiers. Laura Bush was also silent when her husband gutted funded for literacy programs such as Headstart. She didn't do anything to get her husband off his ass during the entire week he did nothing when Hurricane Katrina killed thousands of low income black americans.

So she's Pro-Choice? What has she done about her husband eliminitating Family Planning funding in America and Third World nations?

She was the most innefectual First Lady I can remember in my 54 years. Even Pat Nixon did more than Laura Bush.

What this article conveniently deleted that Laura Bush spent most of her time FUNDRAISING for the Republican Party. She also used her bland "nice-y nice" personality to soften and buffer her wing-nut husband when he would make goofball, blundering statements like "I Am The WAR President" or the "Misson Accomplished" debacle. Laura Bush was used as a public relations foil to soften her husbands failings. I remember seeing her trotted out on Jay Leno and being folksy and charming and he just lapped it up and everyone clapped. It made me want to puke. I suppose next week Alternet will publish an article praising Hitler's sweetheart - Eva Braun?

I hold Laura Bush just as guilty as her husband because she kept her mouth shut, lived in luxury and has been utterly complacent.

Why not write an article praising the wife of the Shah of Iran or Imelda Marcos? They did some very nice charity work and had a stunning wardrobe - just like Laura Bush.

That bit about her going up against Cheney to protect the environment made me want to puke. OK - so she THINKS about things - but what has she ever DONE to take a bold stand and speak up about her concerns?

Nuttin'.

She's retreated back to Dallas and will spend her days writing her memoirs - for which she will get a multi-million deal. Is she going to donate any of that money to Aghan women or kids who can't read? I doubt it. Laura Bush is a Texas socialite - plain and simple. Quit trying to turn her into Mother Theresa.

[« Reply to this comment] [Post a new comment »] [Rate this comment: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5]

» RE: Stuff It Posted by: question
  • AlterNetYour turn

Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.


Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.

Advertisement
Advertisement