Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
Tensions Between Israel, UK Rise Over Killing of Award-Winning Filmmaker
Also in Media and Technology
Michael Jackson's Death Was Tragic, But He Was Little More Than an Icon of Mediocrity
Alisa Valdes-Rodriguez
It's the Right-Wingers Who Are Unloading the Harshest Critiques About Palin’s Bizarre Departure
Eric Boehlert
Will the Tragedy of Michael Jackson's Life Be Inherited By His Kids?
Patricia J. Williams
Summer Blockbusters: Why Do We Insist on Watching Really Bad Movies?
Sameer Pandya
"More Better Faster!": How Our Spastic Digital Culture Scrambles Our Brains
David Bollier
Michael Jackson Was a Freak -- Just Like You and Me
Richard Kim
Britain and Israel face a diplomatic and legal showdown this week over the death of James Miller, an award-winning British film-maker who was shot by Israel soldiers while working on a documentary in the Gaza Strip more than four years ago.
Israel has failed to respond to an ultimatum issued by Lord Goldsmith, the former attorney general, to his opposite number, Meni Mazuz, on 26 June to launch a criminal investigation within six weeks against the officer suspected of firing the fatal shot. The deadline expires tomorrow.
Tel Aviv is refusing to be stampeded. In a previous case -- that of a British student, Tom Hurndall, killed by an Israeli sniper in 2003 -- it eventually yielded to British pressure and court martialled the soldier concerned. He was sentenced to eight years in prison for manslaughter.
The army's first instinct, as shown in both cases, is to protect its soldiers. A military spokesman said that "a cameraman who knowingly enters a combat zone, especially at night, endangers himself."
Moshe Cohen, a spokesman for Israel's Justice Ministry, said in a written statement yesterday that an earlier British request had been thoroughly checked and a decision to close the Miller case had been reported to London. "Now that the British authorities have decided once more to approach us, the matter will be attended to…. A response will be provided in an acceptable fashion, as soon as possible, in accordance with the timetables of the Israeli authorities."
Mr Miller's death was captured on video and was included in the film Death in Gaza, released by HBO in 2004, which went on to win three Emmys. Mr Miller had gone to the troubled region to film children on both sides of the conflict, but he was killed on his last day in Gaza before he could film the other side of the story.
In April, 2006, a London jury at St Pancras coroner's court returned a verdict of unlawful killing and said that Mr Miller, 34, had been "murdered." The Israeli army had dropped the case for want, it said, of enough evidence to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The coroner, Dr Scott Reid, wrote to Lord Goldsmith inviting him to "consider starting criminal proceedings in the UK against members of the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) for an offence of willful killing."
The only soldier who has been named, though only by rank and surname, is Lieutenant Heib, who commanded the armoured vehicle from which the fatal shots were fired.
To try him in Britain, Lord Goldsmith's successor, Baroness Scotland, would have to seek his extradition, which Israel would be expected to resist.
Mr Miller's family accused Israel of "an abject failure to uphold the fundamental and unequivocal standards of international humanitarian and human rights law." They are suing the Israeli government in the Tel-Aviv magistrates' court for compensation.
His wife, Sophy, said after the military investigation was closed: "The truth will come out and we hope the Israeli judicial system will mete out justice. This investigation does not serve the IDF, decent Israeli citizens, us his family, and above all James."
See more stories tagged with: media, israel, uk, miller
Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from Media and Technology! Sign up now »