Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
Spinning Out of Sight
Also in Media and Technology
Will the Tragedy of Michael Jackson's Life Be Inherited By His Kids?
Patricia J. Williams
Summer Blockbusters: Why Do We Insist on Watching Really Bad Movies?
Sameer Pandya
"More Better Faster!": How Our Spastic Digital Culture Scrambles Our Brains
David Bollier
Michael Jackson Was a Freak -- Just Like You and Me
Richard Kim
Jingoism Isn't Journalism: Why I Don't Trust Corporate Media on Iran
Linda Milazzo
In some ways, Armstrong Williams got a bad rap. The conservative black commentator, who was paid by the U.S. Department of Education to advertise and advocate for the controversial No Child Left Behind law, lost his syndicated newspaper column and was pilloried for not disclosing the payment.
Williams did indeed betray the public trust, but he was a small fry a subcontractor who received a mere $240,000 of a one-million-dollar deal between the Education Department and Ketchum, one of the worlds largest public-relations agencies.
And that deal is just the tip of the iceberg.
A recent House Committee on Government Reform investigation launched after similar revelations about two other commentators besides Williams identified Ketchum as the largest recipient of recent PR spending, with contracts totaling more than $100 million. Looking into federal procurement records for contracts with major PR firms since 1997, the committee's minority office also found that the Bush administration doubled the government's PR spending to $250 million, over its first term.
Yet there is little information about what that money was spent on. The lack of transparency is especially alarming given the recent spate of PR-related scandals, which include not just paid commentators but also the use of video news releases (VNRs) aired on TV stations as news reports. The Government Accountability Office issued two rulings declaring the VNRs produced for two federal agencies in violation of the ban on covert government propaganda.
Despite this worrying evidence of misuse of public funds, the top PR companies refuse to disclose the details of their contracts. Requests for information from the PR firms that received at least a million dollars from the federal government since 1997 were met with partial and unsatisfactory answers, at best. None of the firms were willing to share any information not already publicly available including contract agreements or deliverables like studies, brochures and VNRs to clarify what they really did with all that taxpayer money.
Ketchum has received a whopping $100.5 million in federal contracts since 1997. These deals included work for the Education Department; Internal Revenue Service; U.S. Army, to reconnect the Army with the American people and boost recruiting around its 225th birthday; and the Health and Human Services Department, to change the face of Medicare, promote long-term health care planning, encourage preventative care, and present home care information.
Large increases in Ketchums federal work since 2003 mirror the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services PR spending boost, suggesting that their Medicare work may be more extensive than is currently known.
Apart from the scandal surrounding Armstrong Williams, the firm also produced a controversial VNR for the Education Department that promoted tutoring programs under No Child Left Behind, and included then-Education Secretary Rod Paige and PR flack Karen Ryan, who misrepresented herself as a reporter.
Ketchum representatives did not return repeated phone calls making them among the least responsive of the firms contacted by PR Watch.
The recipient of $77 million in federal contracts, Fleishman-Hillard has worked for the Social Security Administration; Library of Congress; Environmental Protection Agency; and the Defense Department, to introduce managed care to employees, due to rising medical costs and decreasing resources.
Diane Farsetta is the Center for Media and Democracy's senior researcher. More information on the PR firms mentioned above can be found on SourceWatch, the Center's online encyclopedia of issues, people and groups shaping the public agenda.
Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from Media and Technology! Sign up now »
| More News and Analysis: | ||
|
Wildfires Are Linked to Global Warming -- But Media Obscure the Relationship Environment: As climate change intensifies, wildfires are going to increase in the U.S. Publicizing the link could help drive home the danger of global warming. By Sam Kornell, Miller-McCune Magazine. July 6, 2009. |
Unemployed and on the Verge of Losing Everything: "I Don't Know How I'll Make It" Corporate Accountability and WorkPlace: Luz Guerra has already lost her job. Now she might lose her car, her home and her health insurance. By Rachel Neumann, AlterNet. July 6, 2009. |
High Noon in Honduras World: The drama in Honduras has moved from the small, impoverished country to the international stage. By Laura Carlsen, AlterNet. July 4, 2009. |