Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
They Shoot Journalists, Dont They?
Also in Media and Technology
Michael Jackson's Death Was Tragic, But He Was Little More Than an Icon of Mediocrity
Alisa Valdes-Rodriguez
It's the Right-Wingers Who Are Unloading the Harshest Critiques About Palin’s Bizarre Departure
Eric Boehlert
Will the Tragedy of Michael Jackson's Life Be Inherited By His Kids?
Patricia J. Williams
Summer Blockbusters: Why Do We Insist on Watching Really Bad Movies?
Sameer Pandya
"More Better Faster!": How Our Spastic Digital Culture Scrambles Our Brains
David Bollier
Michael Jackson Was a Freak -- Just Like You and Me
Richard Kim
CNN has a habit of devouring its own. Whenever the right-wing flak machine cranks up, CNN, like CBS last fall, dispenses with another top executive, producer, or correspondent, no matter how celebrated. The resignation last Friday of CNNs top news executive, Eason Jordan, should be seen in the context of CNNs previous abandonment of its top journalists, like April Oliver and Peter Arnett, and CBS dismissal of top producer Mary Mapes; all of whom raised the ire of the right with the revelation of unflattering facts about the military. But the resignation is also being hailed as more evidence of the power of bloggers to fell their perceived enemies.
In recent weeks, the blogsphere, as it likes to call itself, has been abuzz with vitriol over remarks Jordan made in a panel discussion at the Davos Economic Forum, in which he seemed to suggest that U.S. troops in Iraq shoot at journalists. Importantly, the controversy has obscured the more intriguing question of why international news executives (Richard Sambrook, news chief of the BBC, was also present) were addressing a conference of the global political and economic elite they report on; but such cozy interaction between news executives and the worlds movers and shakers is not uncommon.
According to Massachusetts Congressman Barney Frank, who was also on the Jan. 27 panel with Jordan and recounted the event for the Howard Kurtz of The Washington Post, Jordan said he knew of 12 journalists who were killed by coalition forces in Iraq. According to the Post and The New York Times accounts, Jordans exact wording remains unclear. A videotape is said to have been made by the forum organizers, but has not been released on the grounds that the discussion was to be off the record. Did Jordan say U.S. troops targeted journalists, or didnt he? It is agreed that he later attempted to clarify that he didnt know if any journalists in Iraq were deliberately targeted. In an unprecedented message to blogger and media scholar Jay Rosen, Sambrook (one of the most important global journalists, given the reach, credibility, and agenda-setting power of the BBC) confirmed Barney Franks account and added that he shares Jordans concern about journalists: safety. Since the U.S. invasion, 60 journalists (more or less, depending on which account one consults) have died violently in Iraq while attempting to do their work.
An editorial board member of The Wall Street Journal, who, intriguingly, was also present in Davos, also confirmed the remarks and attempted retraction, and went on to call for Jordans resignation not for lying about the issue, but because Jordan can't be trusted to sit on a panel and field softball questions. It is rather like the Journal, from its position as flagship of the credible conservative American media, is reminding CNN that some things shall not be spoken of. (But, of course, it is TV, not print, reporters who have been dying.) This, more than the blog-feeding frenzy which real journalists purport to ignore, may have inspired Jordan to step down (or inspired some high-up at Time Warner to request he do so).
I referred at the outset to unflattering facts about the U.S. military; but, like CBS truthful, though bungled, expose of the presidents unflattering war record, the facts of the story are all but lost when the conservative flak machine attacks the messenger. Government has no need to defend itself from criticism when popular media like Fox, and its countless devotees in the blogsphere, do so for them. Credible reports of the killing, torture, and harassment of journalists by coalition forces in Iraq have existed since the start of the U.S. invasion, and have been well documented by respected press freedom organizations like the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), Reporters sans frontičres, and the International Federation of Journalists. The historical record suggests a pattern of these activities, but the question of deliberation cannot be answered unless each and every incident is fully, and independently, investigated and to date, that hasnt happened.
Chris Paterson is an assistant professor of media studies at the University of San Francisco and co-editor of International News in the 21st Century (John Libbey/Univ. of Luton, 2004).
Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from Media and Technology! Sign up now »
| More News and Analysis: | ||
|
Huron, California May not Exist in a Year Corporate Accountability and WorkPlace: The unemployment rate in Huron in recent months is “off the charts.” By Viji Sundaram, New America Media. July 9, 2009. |
Energy Industry Threatens Water Quality, Sways Congress With Misleading Data Water: The industry is misleading the public into a false choice between the economy and the environment. By Abrahm Lustgarten, ProPublica. July 9, 2009. |
Summer Downsizing: 31 Ways to Jumpstart Your Local Economy Environment: Here's how to make more with less, put people before profits and cut down on waste. By Sarah van Gelder, YES! Magazine. July 9, 2009. |