Wake Up, America! We're Paying Billions for Personal Financial Advice, and It's Making Us Poorer
Wake up, America! We're paying billions for personal financial advice, and it's making us poorer. From financial "coaches" to leading academics paid to tout dangerous products, members of what former financial columnist Helaine Olen calls the "personal finance industrial complex" are ripping us off, preying on our fears and ensuring that our financial futures are anything but secure. Olen exposes the bogus -- and well-compensated -- advice issuing from the mouths of slick celebrities like Suze Orman, David Bach, Dave Ramsey, and Jim Cramer. She blasts through the mirages of 401(K)s, mutual funds and gimmicks of the do-it-yourself retirement plan that America has foolishingly embraced, along with the real estate schemes and stock market fantasies we turn to when the numbers in our savings accounts don't add up.
In a book that's indispensable to anyone seeking to understand financial reality, Olen reveals the industry's uber-myth: that it's your fault if you're not rich and that tinkering with retirement calculators and investments can save you from financial ruin. That lie, meant to shame and cow us, has a big pay-off for the personal finance predators: it diverts attention from the giant social and economic problems like flat wages, job insecurity and soaring healthcare costs that can bankrupt the most virtuous penny-pincher in the blink of an eye. The antidote to this snakeoil, Olen tells us, is to stop obsessing on our individual financial prospects, and start thinking collectively -- before it's too late.
The following excerpt is adapted from Pound Foolish: Exposing the Dark Side of the Personal Finance Industryby Helaine Olen by arrangement with Portfolio, a member of Penguin Group (USA), Inc., Copyright (c) Helaine Olen, 2013.
The Latté is a Lie: Selling the Myth of the Fiscally Promiscuous American
A quick cup of coffee, a few moments of pleasure. What could be wrong with that? If you ask David Bach, a lot.
According to him, the Starbucks latté is one of the leading sources of our money woes. A former Morgan Stanley money manager, Bach parlayed his experience into multiple book contracts, a nationwide seminar, and ultimately, a regular gig on the Today Show.
Bach believes we can all become millionaires by the time we retire if we arrange to make our savings automatic by having money deducted from every paycheck we receive and funneled into an investment account. It’s not a bad insight as far as savings strategies go. But first people need to find money to invest, and that’s a challenge for Americans. Just under half of us are living paycheck-to paycheck existences at least some of the time, with nary a penny left over for savings.
That’s where Starbucks enters the picture.
Bach calculated that eschewing a $5 daily bill at Starbucks— because who, after all, really needs anything at Starbucks?—for a double nonfat latté and biscotti with chocolate could net a prospective saver $150 a month, or $2,000 a year. If she then took that money and put it all in stocks which, ever an optimist, Bach assumed would grow at an average annual rate of 11 percent a year, “chances are that by the time she reached sixty-five, she would have more than $2 million sitting in her account,” he wrote in his first book, Smart Women Finish Rich, published in 1999. “Are you latté-ing away your financial future?” Bach asked his readers.
People couldn’t get enough of the Latté Factor. It seemed to explain all our woes, all our lack of financial discipline. Give up that latté, and save a six-month emergency fund! It was a simple solution to a long-term problem. “Extraordinary,” said Lester Holt on NBC. An Australian mutual fund company debuted the "Latté Challenge” to get savers to put aside money for retirement (in their funds, of course). The Bank of Nova Scotia announced a deal with Bach in late 2004, buying up 250,000 copies of The Automatic Millionaire to promote its “Find the Money” initiative, which encouraged customers to sign up for automatic deposits in the financial institution’s retirement plans. Search Google today, and you’ll find more than 70,000 unique mentions of the latté factor.