Air BNB Is a Course Correction for a Real-Estate System Stacked Against Us
Stay up to date with the latest headlines via email.
Eric Schneiderman, the New York attorney general, has lots of questions for the residents of the "digital Wild West" who rent out their apartments on Airbnb. Roughly: who are you, where do live and you're making howmuch from your spare room, five flights up and with an unrestricted view of your neighbor's air vent?
All of which misses the exact point of the ingenius pad-crashing service, and the more pressing issue facing users, not lawyers. As those of us with friends who hand over their keys for the weekend know well, there is only one question for occasional landlords on Airbnb, to be asked in a squealy voice and with a face like you just sucked an extra large lemon: how can you let strangers have sex in your bed?!
Ray is 35 years old, a self-confessed "poor scientist", who now and then clears out of his place to let it out on Airbnb. He characterizes his guests as "respectful and cool", with an estimated 70% of them foreign tourists – the kind of foreign tourists who, on the one occasion they broke furniture, hastily offered to pay for it. How they came to break it, of course, is something Ray will never know. But generally, he says, "Airbnb has been fantastic. There are so many in the city who are only just making their rent. It helps a lot of people."
There are roughly 15,000 Airbnb "hosts" in New York and, if you take your information from the courts or the tabloids, they are, variously, scammers, pimps and updated versions of slumlords (not the Donald Sterling kind), avoiding taxes and managing multiple listings under the aegis of a scheme intended for owners renting out their own homes.
Airbnb itself admits there are "bad actors" in the system, and that it has tried to weed them out, but the startup estimates that 87% of listings are in good faith. Other statistics challenge that figure, suggesting that professional landlords abusing the system are responsible for as many as 30% of all listings.
Opposition has forced both sides into more extreme positions than the situation probably warrants, so that regulators have more or less cast Airbnb as a shell company for illegal activity. For its part, Airbnb – a company valued at $10bn, which, as David Streitfeld pointed out at the New York Times on Tuesday, is "more than the Hyatt Hotels Corporation" – has whipped up a petition that practically characterizes itself as a homeless charity:
Many people are struggling in today's economy and ... depend on Airbnb to pay the mortgage and keep the lights on.
If you go looking for wild profiteering, you will find it, as in the case of this Brooklyn bartender making more from Airbnb than he did in his day job. (Until the attorney general shut him down and drove him back onto Craigslist, that is.)
But in the middle of all this are New Yorkers – and residents of other exorbitantly priced cities, primarily San Francisco, which as of this week has its own Airbnb controversy - just trying to catch a break, and tourists to the city, crippled by the unaffordable hotel costs.
So let's clear up a couple of misconceptions.
Firstly, the clientele. Of the three friends of mine who rent out their small, Manhattan apartments every time they go away, none has ever been stung by thieves or prostitutes. Their guests tend to be nerdy Scandinavian students who bring their own breakfast cereal and leave the place tidier than they found it, or single people visiting the city trying to avoid the single supplement hotel charge.