O'Reilly vs. The Doc

Bill O'Reilly.com. Posted February 18, 2005.

Editor's Note: What follows is a transcript of the Feb. 17 broadcast of Fox's The O'Reilly Factor, in which Bill O'Reilly debated Marsha Rosenbaum, director of the drug education program at the Drug Policy Alliance.

O'Reilly: In the "Impact" segment tonight, last New Year's Eve, police arrested a dentist Paul Paxon and his wife Christine in a suburb north of New York City, for allowing their 18-year-old daughter to hold a party where alcohol was present and so were 50 underage teenagers. The case will be heard next May. But joining us now from San Francisco is Dr. Marsha Rosenbaum, the author of the book, Safety First: A Reality-based Approach to Teens, Drugs, and Drug Education.

So you say that maybe this dentist and his wife didn't do anything wrong?

Marsha Rosenbaum: Well, what we know is that despite 2.5 decades now of trying to get teenagers to just say no to alcohol and other drugs, 77 percent of high school students by the time they graduate, have at least tried alcohol.

We know that the prevalence of alcohol is there, even in the best of families. For example, the – President Bush and his wife, their daughters were caught with underage – for underage drinking recently. And so we know it's prevalent.

The question is: What is the most immediate danger that underage drinking poses?

And what we know is that in surveys, 17 percent of 16 to 20-year-olds admit that they drove drunk, and 2,400 teenagers die each year in automobile accidents resulting from alcohol, and so...

O'Reilly: So, what are you saying, that parents should provide alcohol to their children ...

No, but – no, Bill, I'm not saying that. What I'm saying is that if we – if teenagers are not just saying no, matter what we do, we have to have a fall-back strategy ...

O'Reilly: Which is what?

... a Plan B, if you will.

O'Reilly: What is it?

It has to focus on safety. We have to keep teenagers out of cars. I think designated driver programs are a good example of how we can do that here in the Bay area. The American Red Cross, for example, sponsors the Safe Rides programs.

O'Reilly: All right. Nobody – nobody opposes that, and, if there's some kid who's loaded, obviously, you don't want him in the car, and you can give him a ride home. But these – this couple – this is outrageous, and it's not just them. It happens all over the country. They allow their child ...

It does.

O'Reilly: Look, here in New York they raised the drinking age from 18 to 21 because of all the chaos among teenagers who got drunk, all right? So this couple said, 'yes, you can have a New Year's Eve party,' and 50 kids showed up because they're e-mailing everybody that there was booze down there. The parents knew ...

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from DrugReporter! Sign up now »