Voting Rights Lawyers Defeat Texas' Bogus Voter Fraud Prosecutions

By Steven Rosenfeld, AlterNet. Posted May 29, 2008.

A years-long, high-profile campaign by Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott, a Republican, to prosecute elderly Democratic Party volunteers for voter fraud because they helped homebound seniors to vote by mailing their absentee ballots -- but not signing the backs of envelopes -- fell apart on federal court house steps in Texas on Wednesday.

The Attorney General agreed to settle a federal lawsuit challenging the voter fraud prosecutions of the Democratic volunteers rather than go to trial, according to the Lone Star Campaign, which first characterized the AG's prosecutions as politically motivated voter suppression and funded the litigation. Gerald Hebert, an ex-Department of Justice Voting Section Chief and now executive director of the Washington-based Campaign legal Center, represented the Texas Democratic Party and volunteers in the suit.

"Now, none of those people would have never been prosecuted," Hebert told the Associated Press.

Abbott's office also claimed victory in the settlement, although almost all of the legal issues were resolved in the plaintiff's favor. Nonetheless, the attorney general told The New York Times the plaintiffs "discovered that their claims were without basis in fact or law" and "dropped their suit."

The prosecutions

Abbott had spent $1.4 million in discretionary federal law enforcement funds to create a special investigations unit to find and prosecute voter fraud. The same funding source was used in 1999 in Tulia, Texas, where a state undercover agent fabricated cocaine-related charges against three dozen mostly African-American residents that ultimately were overturned and prompted gubernatorial pardons.

While Abbott's voter fraud unit did find and prosecute handful of instances of political operatives pressuring seniors to vote for specific candidates, the task force also prosecuted elderly Democratic Party volunteers -- almost all minorities -- who helped homebound neighbors to vote by assisting them with obtaining and then mailing their absentee ballots. Under a 2003 Texas law, anyone who possesses another person's ballot and does not sign their name on the back of the ballot is guilty of a misdemeanor. Depending on the number of ballots involved, the charge rises to a felony.

Abbott's investigators prosecuted a Texarkana City Council member and her granddaughter for helping seniors vote in this manner. The councilwoman, who pleaded guilty rather than fight the charges, said she wanted to teach her grand daughter about the civic process. In Fort Worth, two investigators spied on an elderly woman while she was showering and then knocked on her front door to question her, traumatizing the woman. That same neighborhood has crack dealers that were ignored by Abbott's investigators while they targeted Democrats. Other targets of the investigations moved out of state.

The prosecutions sent a chill through some of the state's African-American and Latino communities where there is a tradition of neighbors helping other neighbors to vote. The Dallas County Democratic Party stopped sending campaign volunteers to people's homes to help them register to vote. As recently as the day the suit was headed to federal court - Wednesday - Abbott's office told the media, notably The New York Times that "there is no evidence that enforcement has intimidated anyone into stopping voter assistance efforts."

AlterNet.org published an extensive report on Abbott's activities earlier this year that was reprinted as a cover story in The Texas Observer magazine and prompted renewed scrutiny in the Texas and national media of the attorney general's voter fraud task force.

See more stories tagged with: texas, voter fraud, greg abbott

Steven Rosenfeld is a senior fellow at Alternet.org and co-author of "What Happened in Ohio: A Documentary Record of Theft and Fraud in the 2004 Election," with Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman (The New Press, 2006).

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from Democracy and Elections! Sign up now »