Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
Iowa Caucuses, Like the Electoral College, Are Unrepresentative
Share and save this post:
AlterNet Social Networks:
Got a tip for a post?:
Email us | Anonymous form
A big "Amen, Sister!" to Ruth Marcus in the Washington Post, who asks the question so many Floridians and others would like to know, "Who Elected Iowa?"
The caucuses draw a small, unrepresentative sample of a small, unrepresentative state...
...[M]ost Iowans view the caucuses as an obscure art practiced by an elect few. "Usually I don't go, because I'm afraid I'm going to get there and feel like a dummy," one man on Ahn's list confides.And speaking of dummies, I was amazed to see the decision facing one Iowan.
Kay Baccam, 38, who works at an Iowa spice plant, said she liked Thompson but was leaning toward Clinton in part because of her gender.
"She would be the first woman (president) in history. That's a good role model for kids and women," she said.Who winnows down their choices to Fred Thompson or Hillary Clinton? Really.
Political reporters, myself included, get misty over the notion of neighbors gathering on a cold winter night to hash out differences over who is the best candidate. But the caucus process also serves to disenfranchise...
The bizarre rules of the Democratic contest further distort the results. (Republicans employ a more straightforward method: The candidate with the most votes wins.) Why should a candidate who fails to meet the 15 percent threshold of viability walk away empty-handed? Why should the final outcome depend on how those losing campaigns decide where to throw their backing when, in caucus-speak, nonviable preference groups realign for a second round? No wonder the caucus process makes ordinary people's heads hurt...
And perhaps the most important question: Given all this, why do we in the media invest the caucuses with such make-or-break significance?When Florida Democrats were placed under a campaign blackout as punishment for the state legislature changing our primary date, we were told it was essential to the electoral process to preserve the system that lets Iowa and New Hampshire, two of our whitest states, choose first. I have never understood the rationale for this boneheaded move, but I believe it was brought to us by the same folks who sit in Congress now -- unable to do anything different, ineffectual and inaudible, and wondering why the Republicans always win.
| Also in Election 2008 | |||
| Senate Votes to Move Forward on Health-Care Bill: McCain Accuses Reid of Criminal Scheme In debate leading to vote, McCain compared Reid to Madoff, Hatch invoked socialism, and Lincoln promised trouble ahead Post by Adele Stan. November 21, 2009. |
ACORN: Another Super Villain with Super Powers For the trembling patriots of the right. Post by Steve M.. November 21, 2009. |
Tiny Michigan Town Tells Liz Cheney to Take her Fearmongering Elsewhere Someplace where they're all wusses. Post by BarbinMD. November 21, 2009. |
|
EMAIL
PRINT
13 COMMENTS
PERMALINK