Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
College Students Fight for Their Right to Say "F**k Bush"
The Sept. 21 editorial of The Rocky Mountain Collegian was a taunt: TASER THIS...FUCK BUSH. Students groups like the College Republicans and faculty have in fact, obliged -- insofar as they are legally able -- to take down the students responsible.
Or at least the editor in chief, J. David McSwane.
Newspaper editors may be the face of the publication, but the publication is not its editor. The editorial board's decision to run the statement was a 4-3 split, so it's clear that the editor is not the only one who should technically be held accountable. But this isn't really about "journalistic integrity" as the CSU College Republicans would spin it. It is about creating taboo lines around free expression, especially ones that deviate from tamer, 'legitimate' forms of discourse.
The statement itself was a four-word punchline that exercised the right to express a sentiment that many U.S. youth may be feeling. Fuck Bush and Buck Fush stickers and statements are common. Coupled with bizarre tasering incidents at University of Florida, and before that, the brutal tasering of Mostafa Tabatabainejad, a UCLA student in a library, excessive, punitive force seems to be the guard waiting to pounce the moment someone says something out of line.
Whether one agrees with the form or content of the editorial misses the point. Did the UF student Andrew Meyer ramble on too long? Was he an aggressive questioner? All of that is debatable, but trying to silence him with force, bordered on the incredulous. The editorial, was, an exercise of the right to express an opinion, in a completely brazen way, without being silenced.
Wednesday night, a 10-person, faculty-student committee will determine McSwane's fate. If they actually bow down to a puritanical sense of propriety, well, then, fuck 'em.
| Also in Video | |||
| Call Joe Lieberman's Bluff: A Real Fort Hood Inquiry Would Likely Shut Him Up If Lieberman were to actually have his calls for a "terrorism" investigation answered, he probably wouldn't like seeing the results. Post by John Nichols. November 10, 2009. |
President Obama Has Refused to Stand Up for Women, Plain and Simple The president's "toe the line" approach is not acceptable this time. Post by Melissa McEwan. November 10, 2009. |
Korean Warships Exchange Fire on the SK/NK Border The two sides blamed each other for the confrontation, which left one North Korean boat engulfed in flames. Post by Staff. November 10, 2009. |
|
EMAIL
PRINT
55 COMMENTS
PERMALINK