It’s Still a Free Country

By John K. Wilson, AlterNet. Posted September 10, 2002.

On Sept. 11, the Twin Towers weren’t the only structures that came crashing down. So, too, did many civil liberties in America, although most Americans remain unaware of the fact. There were no planes crashing into the Bill of Rights -- only our trusted government officials.

Since, as in wars past, the worst punishments were inflicted upon immigrants or non-white citizens, few Americans spoke out in opposition. A year later, a Freedom Forum poll indicates that a substantial number of Americans express support for limiting freedom in the name of fighting terrorism.

Most Americans think that the worst consequences of terrorist-hunting at home have been shoe doffing at airports or other mere inconveniences. They believe, after years of watching cop shows, that you can't simply hold people incommunicado for months on end without charges, refusing to let them contact an attorney or anyone else.

They're wrong. The "USA-Patriot" Act passed after 9/11 dramatically increased the power of the U.S. government to imprison innocent people for indefinite periods under mere suspicion of some knowledge about terrorist activities.

The new book, "It's a Free Country: Personal Freedom in America after September 11" (RDV Books), edited by Danny Goldberg, Victor Goldberg and Robert Greenwald, challenges the idea widely publicized in the media that domestic liberties were mostly unaffected by terrorism.

One of the most shocking things about "It's a Free Country" is the inclusion of statements by members of Congress. The media presented America post-Sept. 11 as a glorified oneness of thought in support of the war on terror. These sharp criticisms by Reps. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY), Bob Barr (R-Ga.), Barney Frank (D-Mass.) and Dennis Kucinich (D-Ohio) were almost invisible in the press.

The media failed to report the fact, as Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) observed, that the USA Patriot Act was "strengthened" to restrict civil liberties by after-committee "backdoor maneuvers" without the knowledge of members of Congress who voted mere hours after the legislation was finalized to approve it, unaware of the changes made by the Bush Administration.

Suppression of free speech during war has a long history explored in this book. Historian Howard Zinn observes how the U.S. government during World War I prosecuted under the Espionage Act a film called "The Spirit of '76" -- on the grounds that portraying our ally, Britain, as the enemy during the American Revolution was seditious. As Zinn notes, "Without the right to speak freely, to dissent, we cannot evaluate what the government is doing, and so we may be swept into foreign policy adventures with no oppositional voices, and later lament our silence."

Former Illinois Sen. Paul Simon writes, "In moments of passion, administrations can grossly violate our basic civil liberties -- and when those actions are taken in times of tension, the American public will back the president." Simon observes, "It is better to have the unpopular awkwardness of following the Constitution and the law than the popular crudeness of violating our important heritage of freedom."

The book also includes cartoonists and lyrics, including a poem by singer Ani Difranco: "and we holds these truths to be self-evident:/#1 george w. bush is not president/#2 america is not a true democracy/#3 the media is not fooling me."

Making up the core of the book are the stories and testimonials of those who faced retaliation after Sept. 11. Lawyer David Cole tells the stories of unjust detentions; for example, Ali Maqtari, a Yemeni jailed without charges for two months after he accompanied his American wife to Fort Campbell, despite having no links to terrorism and passing a lie detector test. At other times, the war on terrorism seems comical, like the federal agents who investigated a 60-year-old retiree at a gym who criticized Bush's links to the oil industry, or the agents who questioned a North Carolina student for having an anti-Bush poster in her apartment.

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from 9/11: One Year Later! Sign up now »